Why Living Constitutionalism Needs to Be Abandoned

Living Constitutionalism is the practice of interpreting the constitution based upon its meaning in modern society, its tenets being fluid, and it being meant to evolve over time. This view of interpreting the constitution was coined by Justice William J. Brennan, and this practice seems less than true to the document itself. If we look at Article 1: Section 1 of the U.S. constitution it’s clearly stated that “All legislative powers herein granted shall be vested in a Congress of the United States, which shall consist of a Senate and House of Representatives.” Take specific note of the word “herein”. The clause creates the notion that all powers (without exception or addition) granted to congress are listed within the document itself. Implying its parameters as the only ones by which they can exercise power.

To go forward in exercising judicial review in court you must acknowledge such. Brennan runs into a problem here. His constitutional interpretation operates under the assumption of preserving human dignity as it pertains to [what it means] in our time

. The thought of this operates under a premise of the progressive fallacy.  The idea that moving forward automatically means you are going to a better place.

We cannot say for certain that the framers did or did not have a better sense of human dignity than Brennan does currently. To assume him or any future Supreme Court Justice does is quite the arrogant proclamation on such a widely varying social concept. Brennan is seemingly excusing their point of view and supplementing it with his own in order to advance his own agenda. This judicial activism allows the court to operate freely and make rulings that seemingly violate the constitutional supremacy outlined in Article 1: Section 1.

Brennan seems to forget that interpreting the constitution as the framers did does not leave the document unmalleable to time, as the constitution has granted the legislature the ability to amend the constitution given they are successful in meeting the parameters for amendment as outlined in Article 5 of the U.S. Constitution. By asserting he has a duty as a justice on the Supreme Court to uphold human dignity in a modern context (with no regard of the law’s constitutional and historical context), he may actually be violating his judicial authority and undermining Congress’s constitutionally granted power as well as state powers given by Article 1 Section 1 and Amendment 10.

The duty of the court after Justice Marshall began the tradition of judicial review in Marbury vs. Madison is to interpret laws made by Congress as constitutional or unconstitutional. Not to stop Congress from permitting actions you disagree with based upon Brennan’s or anyone else’s progressive view of human dignity which may or may not be beneficial to the society at large.


Joseph T Enders II

Joe Enders is a true story of American success. Now only a college student, he has overcome homelessness, abuse, and poverty. He was an activist for Turning Point U.S.A. and a campus coordinator for his school. He graduated with an associates degree in arts with honors from the college of DuPage and is currently working towards his bachelors in Politics, Economics, and Philosophy at The King’s College. A school at which a majority of his tuition was paid for in scholarships and grants, and will soon be graduated in May of 2018. Well versed in Trump Era politics, he successfully predicted the election of Donald Trump and even predicted him losing the popular vote. Joe believes his brand of right wing politics is the future for America and the conservative movement. Joe has been rapidly gaining popularity in the young Conservative movement. A frequent invitee of Conservative activist conferences, he has met and engaged with some of the most important figures in politics. He is even mentioned in the book by Turning Point USA founder, Charlie Kirk.

Please leave a reply to voice your thoughts.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s